Dark Views

TED (conference) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Barry schwartz held an excellent talk at TED: “Our loss of wisdom” (YouTube, full lesson on TED Ed). A few quotes (not all of them are literal):

• The job description of a hospital janitor includes many kinds of tasks but not a single one involves other human beings. Not one. Yet, when you look at what janitors tell you when you ask them about your job, it’s always about other people:
  • Mark stopped mopping the floor because a patient had got up and did exercises in the corridor.
  • One janitor refused to vacuum the visitors lounge because family members slept there despite orders of her superior.
  • Luke washed the floor in a comatose patients room twice because a relative hadn’t noticed him doing it the first time.
• Not all janitors are like this but those who are think these are essential parts of the job.
• “These janitors have the moral will to do right by other people and beyond this the moral skill to figure out what doing right means.”
• “A Wise Person Knows: When and how to make ‘the exception to every rule.'”
• “A Wise Person Knows: When and how to improvise.”
• “A Wise Person Knows: How to use these moral skills in pursuit of the right aims.”
• “A Wise Person: Is made and not born.”
• It takes experience to become wise and not just any experience: You need the permission to be allowed to improvise, to try new things, occasionally to fail and to learn from your failures.
• “You don’t need to be brilliant to be wise. The bad news is that without wisdom, brilliance isn’t enough.”
• @05:57, he tells a story how people with good intentions ruin the lives of a family for several weeks just by obediently following rules. All people involved said “we hate to do it but we have to follow procedure.”
• “Rules and procedures may be dumb but they spare you from thinking.” (- and they allow you to blame others)
• When things go wrong, we turn to two tools: Rules and incentives. When something happens, we want better ones and more of them. That happened after the financial crisis: Regulate, regulate, regulate, fix the incentives, fix the incentives, fix the incentives. @8:21 “The truth is: Neither rules nor incentives are enough to do the job.” How do you pay people a bonus for being emphatic?
• Rules and incentives help in the short run but they create a downwards spiral in the long run.
• By relying on rules, we engage in a war on wisdom. Rules help prevent disaster but they also ensure mediocrity (@10:30). We need enough rules but not too many.
• Incentives seem better. But sometimes, they compete with the original goal instead of complementing it. We suddenly stop asking “What is my responsibility?” and turn to “What serves me best?”
• Solution? Smarter incentives. Unfortunately, there will never be incentives which will be smart enough. We need incentives but excessive incentives demoralize: “It causes people who engage in that activity to lose morale and it causes the activity itself to lose morality.”
• “We must ask, not just is it profitable, but is it right.” – Barack Obama, 18th Dec 2008.
• What doesn’t work: Teach more ethics courses. “There is no better way to show people that you’re not serious than to tie everything you have to say about ethics in a ball and consign it to the margins as an ethics course.”
• What to do instead? See for yourself @14:25

This entry was posted on Sunday, February 3rd, 2013 at 19:09 and is filed under Philosophy. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.